Articles | Open Access | DOI: https://doi.org/10.37547/tajpslc/Volume07Issue02-10

Legal and procedural challenges in appointing audits as investigative actions

Barakayev Lazizjon Otaqulovich , PhD, Law Enforcement Academy of the Republic of Uzbekistan, Tashkent, Uzbekistan

Abstract

The article comprehensively analyzes the problems associated with appointing an audit as an investigative action. The study examines the procedural order of audit appointment, its legal foundations, the content of the audit appointment decree, and issues of its documentation. The paper also analyzes errors and shortcomings made by investigators, interrogators, and courts when appointing audits, and their causes. The article discusses the investigator's preparation process before appointing an audit, audit timeframes, and issues of selecting and engaging auditors. The research puts forward proposals on the need to involve specialists in the audit appointment process, implement a mechanism for appealing audit decisions, clearly define audit deadlines, and improve requirements for documenting audit appointment orders. Additionally, suggestions are made regarding the improvement of the procedural regulations for audit appointments and the expansion of legal guarantees in this process. The research results serve to improve the practice of investigating economic crimes.

Keywords

Audit, investigative action, audit decree

References

Savina L.A. Organization and tactics of preliminary verification of reports on economic crimes. Moscow, 2006. - p. 22.

Astanov I.R. "Procedural and forensic aspects of using special knowledge in criminal cases" Dissertation prepared for obtaining the degree of Doctor of Legal Sciences (DSc). –Tashkent: 2020. – p. 93.

Eremin S.G. Organization of documentary audit and auditor's verification at the request of law enforcement agencies to identify circumstances of crimes // "Black holes" in Russian legislation. – 2006 - №2. – p. 233.

Astanov I.R. "Procedural and forensic aspects of using special knowledge in criminal cases" Dissertation prepared for obtaining the degree of Doctor of Legal Sciences (DSc). –Tashkent: 2020. – p. 93.

Muminov B.A. "Improving the use of special economic knowledge in pre-trial proceedings" Dissertation prepared for obtaining the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) in Legal Sciences –Tashkent: 2018. – p. 71.

Law of the Republic of Uzbekistan "On amendments and additions to the Criminal, Criminal Procedure and Administrative Liability Codes of the Republic of Uzbekistan". Article 2, Clause 2. 20.07.2018 URQ-485. //www.lex.uz

Muminov B.A. "Improving the use of special economic knowledge in pre-trial proceedings" Dissertation prepared for obtaining the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) in Legal Sciences –Tashkent: 2018. – p. 73.

Article 12 of the Law of the Republic of Uzbekistan "On Operational-Search Activity". //www.lex.uz

Letter No. 9/3-1506-23 dated June 21, 2023, from the Department for Combating Economic Crimes (in response to letter No. 15/05a-23 dated June 15, 2023, from the Prosecutor General's Office). Letter No. 20/4-67502 dated June 24, 2023, from the Tax Committee (in response to letter No. 15/05a-23 dated June 15, 2023, from the Prosecutor General's Office). Letter No. 14/8-01549 dated June 23, 2023, from the State Financial Control Inspection (in response to letter No. 15/05a-23 dated June 15, 2023, from the Prosecutor General's Office)

Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Uzbekistan //www.lex.uz

Yeruzayev A.S. "On the issue of regulating requirements for conducting audits and documentary verification" - pp. 34-38.

Bystryakov E.N., Shadrin V.V. "Methods of investigating crimes in the economic sphere." "Investigation of certain types of crimes: textbook / Edited by V.I. Komissarov. Saratov. Saratov State Law Academy Publishing House, 2003. – p. 101.

Stepanov V.V. "Preliminary examination of primary materials on crimes" - p. 88.

Astanov I.R. "Procedural and forensic aspects of using special knowledge in criminal cases" Dissertation prepared for obtaining the degree of Doctor of Legal Sciences (DSc). –Tashkent: 2020. – p. 96.

Vakhobov F.V. "Specific features of procedural documents in preliminary investigation" dissertation prepared for obtaining the degree of Candidate of Legal Sciences. –Tashkent: 2011. – p. 96. http://diss.natlib.uz/ru-RU/ResearchWork/OnlineView/38297

Inogomjonova Z.F. Abdurakhmanov U.A. Procedural documents in criminal cases. Study guide – Tashkent: TSUL publishing house, 2006. - p. 18.

Krivenko T.D. Audits in cases of crimes resulting in livestock deaths // Control over the preservation of socialist property: collection of scientific works. - Moscow, 1983. - p. 101.

Conducting documentary audit on the instructions of investigator and court. Methodological letter for experts, investigators and judges. - Moscow, 1982. - p. 17.

Zhuravlev S.Yu. Investigation of economic crimes. - Moscow: Yurlitinform, 2005. - p. 51.

Sergeev L.A. Audit in crime investigation. - p. 88.

Golubyatnikov S.R., Tselishchev A.Ya. Fundamentals of accounting and forensic accounting expertise: Textbook for special secondary educational institutions of the USSR Ministry of Internal Affairs, Moscow: VYuZSh MVD USSR, 1990, p. 181. Sologub N.M., Evdokimov S.S., Danilova N.A. "Embezzlement in the economic sphere. Crimes and their detection: methodological guide, Moscow: Prior 2002. – p. 197.

Boyko V.F., Zhirny G.E. "Issues of improving the quality of investigation and court proceedings in criminal cases of embezzlement in the public catering system." // Forensics and forensic expertise: Republican interdepartmental scientific-methodological collection. - Issue 30. - Kiev; Kiev State University "Higher School" Publishing Association Publishing House, 1985. – p. 32.

Sorokotyagin I.N. "Special knowledge in crime investigation" / Sverdlovsk Law Institute, Rostov University Publishing House, 1984. – p. 21.

Astanov I.R. "Procedural and forensic aspects of using special knowledge in criminal cases" Dissertation prepared for obtaining the degree of Doctor of Legal Sciences (DSc). –Tashkent: 2020. – p. 102.

Kozitsin Ya.M., "Investigation and consideration of embezzlement crimes committed using official position." Study guide. Sverdlovsk, 1975. - pp. 109-110.

Article 19 of the Law of the Republic of Uzbekistan "On State Control of Business Entities' Activities". // www.lex.uz

Dzhumamuratov Sh.Ya. Organization and conduct of documentary audits and forensic accounting expertise in investigating theft of state and public property. - pp. 12-13.

Tax Code of the Republic of Uzbekistan. Article 88. //www.lex.uz

Article 29 of the Law of the Republic of Uzbekistan "On Accounting". //www.lex.uz

Abdirova G.A. Use of special economic (accounting) knowledge in investigating crimes committed in the banking sector (according to the criminal procedure legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan). - Diss. ... Cand. of Legal Sciences. - Chelyabinsk, 2003. - pp. 91-92.

Khmyrov A.A. Investigation of theft of state and public property: study guide for VYUZI students. - Moscow, 1970. - p. 81.

Article Statistics

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Copyright License

Download Citations

How to Cite

Barakayev Lazizjon Otaqulovich. (2025). Legal and procedural challenges in appointing audits as investigative actions. The American Journal of Political Science Law and Criminology, 7(02), 56–64. https://doi.org/10.37547/tajpslc/Volume07Issue02-10